OK, it’s late at night and I’ve had several glasses of red wine. My other half is asleep on the sofa and I’m listening to some of my favorite 80s tunes on YouTube. I’ve just had the idea to do a little experiment and perform a comparison of the comparison websites! Yes I AM that sad!! But hey, it will be interesting to see if they come up with the same results. For this highly technical experiment I will be assuming the identity of one Mr Philippe Flop, a 40 something French sandal enthusiast who now resides in Rotherham.
I am with British Gas for gas on their standard tariff paying £60 per month direct debit.
On Electricity I am with Npower and I pay £40 per month. I am on Npowers standard tariff too!
The comparison sites I will be comparing are -
USwitch
Money Supermarket
Energy Helpline
Confused
GoCompare
OK, without further ado, it’s on with the test.
USwitch
The site is pretty bland looking but serves the job. I inputted my details which was really easy. It took less that a minute to come up with the following best deal -
Scottish Power Online Energy Saver 14 – Saving £179.29 per year
Money Supermarket
Started off really well. The site is easy to navigate and once you’ve put your postcode and house number in things went pretty smoothly. One frustrating aspect is that you cannot proceed until you enter your email address. Presumably this is so they can send you marketing stuff about Viagra and six-pack abs. Or is that just my email account?
Everything was going fine until – “We are experiencing a technical error blah blah blah”
So I gave it 10 minutes and tried again only to be greeted with the same message!! They can naff off now. They are eliminated from my experiment. They will be sorry I tell you!

Energy Helpline
Ok, I’ll be honest. I really like Energy Helpline. From loading the site up it took me just 45 seconds to get a quote. It’s really easy to fill in the forms and they don’t require an email address. The really big plus for Energy Helpline is that they don’t just show you tariffs that you can switch to through them. They genuinely show you the cheapest tariffs, even if they won’t be earning any commission from the sale. USwitch claim to do this, but in my experiment today those product’s didn’t seem to show! tut tut.
The best deal showing on Energy Helpline is -
Scottish Power Direct October 2012 – Saving £197 per year
Confused
I don’t know who designed this website. Maybe it’s the wine or YouTube randomly deciding to play me MC Hammer that’s distracting me but this site is quite hard to read. Then it seems to take forever to come up with a result. OK 1 minute 23 seconds is not long but in the context of “You can’t touch this” it feels like an eternity! They also insist that you check a box to say that you have read the terms and conditions. Yeah right!
Then your presented with a big tick that says “show me my prices”

I’m exited I tell you. My finger is trembling with anticipation as I click my mouse.
Confused.com offer me the same deal as USwitch but with a bigger saving of £0.05!!
Scottish Power Online Energy Saver 14 – Saving £179.34 per year
GoCompare
I start my stop watch and log onto the site. Oh my eyes!! This one is even more hideous than confused.com. The colour scheme is shocking and the selection boxes are so small it’s almost impossible to read them. It only takes 57 seconds to come up with a quote and I didn’t have to enter my made up email address.
Guess who comes out top’s with GoCompare? -
Scottish Power Online Energy Saver 14 – Saving £179.38 per year
That’s 9 pence cheaper than USwitch and we all know that you can buy Asda’s smart price noodles for 9p. I love noodles.
Conclusion
Get a life and quit reading pointless blogs about gas and electricity comparison websites!
Seriously; I can draw the following conclusion -
The award for best comparison site is – Energy Helpline

The best energy deal at the moment if you live in Yorkshire is – Scottish Power Direct 2012 but then they did say that they are putting there prices up in August, so you best option would be to move to a warmer country or lay down in a dark room.
If your looking to save some dough, Go to Energy Helpline (click the picture above) and get yourself signed up on a fixed deal before prices go up even more and the world ends, in which case you wouldn’t pay your energy bills would you?